The Science Behind Cavities

The Science Behind Cavities: What Actually Causes Tooth Decay?

Cavities, or dental caries, are often misunderstood as simply being caused by sugar. While sugar plays a role, the process of tooth decay is a complex biochemical interaction involving pH levels, bacterial activity, and mineral dynamics within the enamel and dentin.

The Chemistry of Tooth Demineralization

Tooth enamel is primarily composed of hydroxyapatite, a crystalline form of calcium phosphate. When exposed to acids produced by bacterial metabolism, particularly Streptococcus mutans and Lactobacillus, the pH of the oral environment drops. This acidic environment leads to demineralization, a process in which calcium (Ca²⁺) and phosphate (PO₄³⁻) ions are dissolved from the enamel.

The critical pH for hydroxyapatite demineralization is approximately 5.5, meaning that when the oral pH falls below this level, enamel begins to break down. In contrast, fluorapatite—a fluoride-modified form of hydroxyapatite—has a lower critical pH of around 4.5, making it more resistant to acid attacks. For reference, the pH of lemon juice is 2.0, and soda ranges from 2.5 to 3.0. Soda often contains phosphoric acid, and it is this acid that primarily leads to cavities.

Fluoride itself is not naturally part of the tooth structure but can integrate into the enamel as fluorapatite when present in the oral environment. Some believe fluoride strengthens teeth by forming a more acid-resistant crystalline structure, but its overall impact is debated due to potential negative systemic effects and the need for further research.

What is Lost in Demineralization?

During demineralization, the primary elements lost from the enamel include:

• Calcium (Ca²⁺)

• Phosphate (PO₄³⁻)

• Hydroxyl groups (OH⁻)

• 
  

This loss weakens the enamel, making it more susceptible to further acid attacks. Once minerals are lost at a rate exceeding natural remineralization, a cavity begins to form.

The Sugar vs. Acid Experiment

Imagine placing a tooth in a concentrated sugar solution—it would remain largely unaffected. Now, place a tooth in an acidic solution, and over time, it will dissolve until nothing is left. This illustrates the real culprit behind cavities: acid. While sugar fuels bacterial activity that leads to acid production, it is ultimately the acid that causes enamel to break down, not sugar itself.

In reality, the problem isn't just sugar but also the foods that feed and harbor bacteria. Sticky foods like chips, crackers, and other processed carbohydrates can be worse than sugar because they cling to teeth and provide a long-lasting food source for bacteria. Anything that feeds and harbors bacteria contributes to decay, making diet a crucial factor in cavity prevention.

How to Remineralize a Tooth

Remineralization is the process of restoring lost minerals back into the enamel. This can be achieved through various methods:

1. Amorphous Calcium Phosphate (ACP) - A bioavailable form of calcium and phosphate that helps redeposit minerals onto demineralized enamel.

2. Casein Phosphopeptide-Amorphous Calcium Phosphate (CPP-ACP, Recaldent™) - A milk-derived protein that stabilizes calcium and phosphate, increasing their bioavailability for enamel repair.

3. Hydroxyapatite Toothpaste - A synthetic form of hydroxyapatite that can directly integrate into enamel, potentially replacing lost mineral structure.

4. pH Control - Saliva plays a critical role in remineralization by buffering acids and providing a source of calcium and phosphate. Using baking soda on a toothbrush can help neutralize acids in the mouth, preventing further demineralization.

5. Dietary Adjustments - Avoiding acidic foods and beverages is essential, as acids contribute to demineralization. Many processed and natural foods contain acids in various forms, so checking ingredient lists for acidic components (such as citric acid, phosphoric acid, and ascorbic acid) can help minimize exposure.

6. Xylitol - A sugar alcohol that inhibits S. mutans growth and increases saliva flow, contributing to a less acidic environment.

7. Arginine - An amino acid found in saliva that helps neutralize acid and supports the growth of beneficial oral bacteria, reducing cavity risk.

8. Silver Diamine Fluoride (SDF) - A compound used to arrest caries by both killing cavity-causing bacteria and forming a mineral layer over demineralized areas.

Additional Factors Influencing Tooth Decay

The Role of Saliva in pH Regulation

Saliva is the mouth’s natural defense mechanism against acid. It contains essential proteins like statherin and histatins, which help regulate mineral balance and inhibit bacterial growth. Saliva also helps wash away food particles and buffer acids to maintain a neutral pH.

Individual Susceptibility to Cavities

Genetics, variations in salivary composition, and differences in the oral microbiome influence cavity risk. Some individuals naturally produce more acid-resistant enamel or have beneficial bacterial populations that reduce acidity.

The Impact of Oral Hygiene on pH

Plaque acts as a biofilm that traps acids against the teeth, creating a localized acidic microenvironment. Regular brushing and flossing disrupt bacterial colonies, reducing acid exposure and maintaining a healthier oral pH.

Primary Sources of pH Change

Intrinsic Factors (Within the Body)

• Acid Reflux (GERD) – Stomach acid exposure lowers oral pH.

• Dry Mouth (Xerostomia) – Reduced saliva impairs buffering capacity.

• Metabolic Disorders – Some conditions alter saliva composition and pH.

• Frequent Vomiting (e.g., Eating Disorders, Pregnancy, Chronic Illness) – Brings stomach acid into direct contact with teeth.

• Chronic Inflammatory Conditions – Some systemic conditions impact oral pH balance.

Extrinsic Factors (External Influences)

• Dietary Acids – Citrus, soda, vinegar, and processed foods lower pH.

• Medications – Some have acidic properties or reduce saliva flow.

• Dehydration – Leads to reduced saliva production and buffering.

• Alcohol Consumption – Both acidic and drying to oral tissues.

• Environmental Exposure – Habitual acid exposure (e.g., industrial environments, excessive citrus consumption).

• Frequent Snacking – Leads to prolonged acid production by bacteria.

Balancing Remineralization and Decay

Tooth decay is ultimately a battle between demineralization and remineralization. While fluoride is often cited as beneficial for strengthening enamel, its role is primarily in reducing solubility rather than directly rebuilding lost mineral structures. Alternative approaches, such as hydroxyapatite and calcium phosphate supplementation, provide pathways for natural enamel repair without the systemic concerns associated with fluoride.

Understanding the underlying chemistry of cavities allows for a more informed approach to prevention and treatment. By maintaining a balanced oral environment, optimizing pH, and ensuring adequate mineral availability, it is possible to reduce the risk of tooth decay and promote long-term oral health.